“...one Nation under God. INDIVISIBLE, with liberty and…”
“DIVISIBLE.” That’s how an old fellow historian described his recitation at that point in the Pledge of Allegiance. “But the Civil War ‘settled’ the question of the divisibility of the Union once and for all!” Do feats of arms really decide such questions; or are universal truths transcendent?
Two of our Founding Fathers (Thomas Jefferson and James Madison) authored in 1798 (as responses to Federalist tariff policies) the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions. Briefly, the documents presented the argument via those two states’ legislatures that the federal government was the product of the state governments; and the pre-existing state governments maintained the ability to refuse to comply with unconstitutional actions taken by the national government. But hey, what unique bonafides did those two jocks possess concerning the DNA of our republican form of government, anyway?
During the Jackson Administrations, Vice President John C. Calhoun (who resigned the vice presidency for an open US Senate seat) led the resistance in the Palmetto State to the federal “Tariff of Abominations.” President Jackson threatened to (as President Washington had done in fact during the 1794 Whiskey Rebellion) lead the US Army himself into South Carolina if it continued to challenge the Supremacy Clause to the US Constitution. The bluff worked (Congress slowly dismantled the hated tariffs), but again: Was Jackson’s position based upon a republican form of government fact?
There’s been much speculation over the last decade as to whether or not this nation could again see internecine bloodshed? How might such a conflict begin?
Let us imagine an authoritarian Democrat takeover of all three branches of the federal government. I have every confidence such a situation would be leveraged to the max by said extremists. (We saw with our own eyes their trial run circa 2020-2022.) After having packed the Supreme Court with four more justices and the Senate with four senators from two new states; a raft of patently unconstitutional court opinions and federal laws could then be met by conservative states and local governments with the response of: “We will not comply.” Then what?
We’ve seen in recent years lesser examples of this type of state/local resistance; whether it be states who have legalized recreational use of marijuana in defiance of the federal government’s Schedule I status of that drug: The feds have looked the other way. The 2014 Bundy Ranch Standoff: The feds took an unusually “hands-off” approach. But what if a cocksure President Newsom sends federal agents into southern/western states who refuse to allow federal enforcement of new federal laws which those state and/or local governments declare are clearly unconstitutional? (Supreme Court justices aren’t the only Americans with the gift of comprehending the English language.)
Much has been made of the militarization of state and local police forces around the nation during the GWOT decades. The next Ft. Sumter could occur when federal agents move against those heavily armed state and/or local paramilitary organizations. Do you really believe after the Civil War the US Government simply “forgot” to put Jefferson Davis on trial for treason? That’s referred to as a “clue” in the investigations world.
Next Week: President Martin Van Buren’s Foreign Policy Big Idea
Shane Morris is a retired soldier and teacher. Contact at sigm11@yahoo.com (Subject: NtC)
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here